ANTI-AGING TINTED EYE SERUMS: Comparing three brands

This post contains affiliate links. Any purchases made from using these links may result in a small commission to me - thank you!

COMPARING TINTED EYE SERUMS / BRIGHTENERS

GARNIER - DRMTLGY - JOAH

I love a good tinted eye serum, eye brightener and something that makes my eyes look like I am wide awake (even on 5 hours of sleep).

Right?

I try several and I have a few I can share that are all gooooood.

They are super cheap to a little more of a splurge. However, all are worth a look.

Starting with the GARNIER SkinActive Clearly Brighter Anti-Dark Circle Eye Roller, Sheer Tint Light/Medium, 0.5 Fl Oz (15mL)

LINK: https://amzn.to/3QyJIxJ

This is the one I started with and I bought it at a drugstore. Now I find it only online…not sure why because it’s not bad. There is a LOT of competition in this area so maybe it’s just phased out.

But…there are a couple of issues.

The roller is nice, but it dispenses a LOT of product so I usually use my finger to roll a little on and then dab around my eye.

It’s not as hydrating as the others. It’s not drying, it just needs a little dab of eye cream used with it (in my opinion).

It kind of defeats the point of using a roller, but sometime I use the roller and just blend what is dispensed.

It’s cheap, it’s effective.

It give a nice coverage to dark circles, redness. It is a little less hydrating than the other two, but for a quick coverup and smoothing, it’s pretty good.

DRMTLGY

DRMTLGY Luminous Eye Corrector SPF 41, Under Eye Color Corrector for Dark Circles, Anti-Aging Tinted Eye Cream, Hydrating Eye Serum

LINK: https://amzn.to/3EUxEo4

The newest is the DRMTLGY (the high-end of the three) but worth it (in my opinion).

DRMTLGY Luminous Eye Corrector SPF 41, Under Eye Color Corrector for Dark Circles, Anti-Aging Tinted Eye Cream, Hydrating Eye Serum

LINK: https://amzn.to/3EUxEo4

What I like about it:

A wonderful, cooling pen that has smoothing effect on the eye.

The serum (tinted) is pretty good coverage, so I don’t really need any additional concealer. Once applied, my eyes look like dark circles and redness are toned down and the overall area looks smoother and brighter.

It’s pricier than the others, but when I really need a good boost or before events or when I want to look my best, this is the go-to for me.

It’s a little bit of luxury buy (not too bad) but it is a very nice product. I would potentially re-purchase!

JOAH Perfect Complexion Under Eye Concealer and Hydrating Serum, Korean Makeup for Dark Circles and Puffiness, Peptide Serum with Medium Coverage, Cushion Tip Applicator

LINK: https://amzn.to/4hUHftw

JOAH Perfect Complexion Under Eye Concealer and Hydrating Serum, Korean Makeup for Dark Circles and Puffiness, Peptide Serum with Medium Coverage, Cushion Tip Applicator

LINK: https://amzn.to/4hUHftw

What I like about it:

This is a really good option - cheap, easy to get (amazon) and it works nicely giving both coverage and an anti-aging serum in just a swipe.

K-beauty with peptides and buildable coverage.

It comes in several shades so you can choose your best.

I bought one in a far-too-light color so I’m using it up and going to go a little deeper with my next order, but it is a lovely light serum with coverage.

I generally use a little concealer over it (only because it’s too light), but in the right color I might not need it.

I LOVE how easy it is to use. It has a cushion sponge (not a metal roller or applicator like the other two), but I can swipe or dab it on easily.

SUMMARY - WHICH IS BEST?

I really like all three. No clear winner, but these are my choices:

The GARNIER is probably my least favorite because it’s not as hydrating - I usually mix it with just a little eye cream to apply it. It’s cheap and easy to use for everyday use.

The DRMTLGY is a beautiful product. If you are looking for a good serum with peptides, ceramides, SPF and nice coverage, this is a winner.

The JOAH is a great fit between the two — it has a nice serum, it’s lightweight, hydrating and give a nice coverage. It’s also very affordable. Great for everyday!

Need a great eye cream?

Luxe option with gold HEVATOX GOLD EYE LIFT CREAM - beautiful formula with lifting and gold for firming and smoothing

Affordable and easy option in a stick TULA SKIN CARE EYE BALM - super easy eye balm in a stick (makes eyes look brighter instantly!)